Now if they used bacon grease instead of ice cream Peanut ButterSweet Jesus is this delicious. To construct these amazing fries, Five Guys starts with their regular, boardwalk-style method. Keep an eye out for the milkshake menu at Five Guys locations in New York and New Jersey as they continue to expand, and pray to the fast-food gods that those peanut butter and Double Stuf. If you want, try it with Kahlua, a chocolate liqueur, vodka, brandy, bourbon or vodka. Specialties: Your nearby Five Guys at 2 Metrotech Center in Brooklyn is ready to offer you a classic take on burgers, hot dogs, fries, milkshakes and more. How to Make A Five Guys Grilled Cheese. The other is to start with a vanilla or chocolate ice cream and to add coffee for the coffee flavor. } ); Our taste test weeded out the best of the best for our chocolate lovers. Our verdict: Five Guys milkshakes are worthy of your love. We think youre delicious as you are. The essential Five Guys order:Do you really want to live like you're dying, as the Tim McGraw song I heard while in a Five Guys passionately suggested? Five Guys' peanut butter milkshake has a vanilla base (as all of their shakes do), blended with natural, creamy peanut butter. You taste some chocolate but you mostly just taste ice. It's a BLT, after all, with a strong emphasis on the "B." The veggie sandwich served up at Five Guys is downright divisive. "If you can give a good haircut or if you can serve a good drink at a bar or if you can serve a good hamburger, you can always make money in America." But its still somehow smooth enough to drink through a straw, so its not really ice cream either so it is kind of a milkshake? The Oreo Cookie Pieces milkshake is exactly as advertised. This is just the right amount of guys.. They're not chasing the customer, they're letting the customer come to them. At Five Guys, the milkshakes are made with just a few simple ingredients: primarily milk, nonfat milk, sugar, whey, and whatever toppings you choose to have mixed in to your creation, so you know exactly what you're getting when you order one of these hand-spun milkshakes. You dont expect a milkshake from Del Taco to be good but this is probably the best strawberry milkshake in the fast-food universe. The only problem with this otherwise-epic masterpiece is an issue similar to the one we experienced with the veggie sandwich: there's a lot of meat, here, and not a lot of moisture to hold it all together. For extra flavor, add in broken peanut butter cups or top with whipped cream and a little chocolate sauce. Also known as "Double Chocolate" or "Chocolate Overload", this milkshake is for true chocoholics only. Maybe, but I love a good Oreo shake and Jack in the Box is probably the reason why. Go with the BLT. Joe Molander I went to Five Guys for the. Arbys also drizzles some chocolate syrup on the whipped cream, which is a strong move and helps the whipped cream seem like more than just an over-sweetened visual component. A good chocolate milkshake has a great balance of that rich chocolatey goodness, but it should be creamy enough that it's not just ice cream in a cup. The real substance of this shake is so delicious that you won't want to waste time on a fairly generic and sweet tuft of whipped cream before getting to the real good stuff. Its just way too sweet. There are eight different burgers plus the option to add up to 15 different free toppings sandwiches, hot dogs, and two different kinds of fries. We agree, as one look at the finished hot dog will confirm. Who wouldve thought Sonic was this good at anything? Remember our qualm with the bacon burger? For the most part, the chocolate milkshake at Chick-fil-A was notour pleasure to sip on. Dont be a shallow milkshake drinker, the milkshake is a generous and beautiful snack. Heres Our Review Of Cocaine Bear: Oh Hell Yes! One Star/Guy Who is Kinda Sad:The worst thing on the menu, quite predictably, was the Veggie sandwich. Dogs. If you're going to go with any hot dog at Five Guys, just lean into this big boy. Five Guys founder Jerry Murrell's mother. They have a range of flavors from the simple to the more unexpected, like bacon. But the real beauty of Five Guys is the fact that, actually, you don't have to choose. Salted caramel, chocolate, oreo cookies, and malted milk. Better yet, go banana fudge! But not like this. And although a vanilla milkshake base is best, you can also use strawberry ice cream (or aberry gelato) for a "very berry" flavor. Its a f*cking milkshake, how did you screw this up? Im always actively rooting against Chick-fil-A but credit where credit is due. Anyone got any other suggestions? One of the things I love about Five Guys is that the menu is completely customizable but doesnt lack character like a build your own pizza place or the food from Chipotle, and the customizability extends to the milkshakes. Like the famousmalted milkshake, the butterscotch milkshake was hugely popular years ago and has now become acult classic. } Five Guys knows what it's doing and, from sixth place forward, there is really nothing major to complain about. At first glance, it's merely tan-colored, with small specks of peanut butter barely visible. Some locations may also have other options, but they're either a bit boring (like vanilla or chocolate), or not available in enough locations to fairly rank them. Bananas are usually addedin chocolate or vanilla milkshakes. All locations WI Onalaska 3025 S. Kinney Coulee Rd. Popular Five Guys Menu Items, Ranked Worst To Best. ", Our other shocked editor wrote a note to you all. Top with pieces of homemade peppermint patties and a fresh sprig of mint, or with whipped cream and a drizzle of chocolate sauce. The patty melt benefits from the fact that they flip over a regular bun and double grill it with what would normally be the inside of the bun as the outside, and two layers of cheese encasing the burger patty. In execution, however, because of the unfortunate aforementioned cheese choice, the flavor combination is simply not worth treating yourself to. Plant-based burgers, blind taste testing ketchup, knocking back shots of olive oil there comes a time when a food writer must ask his editor: Do I ever get to eat anything fun?, But Dane, he replies. ", "Sooo chocolatey," another editor wrote. Shortbread cookies are good in a chocolate milkshake. 30 Calories 7-28 Carbs (g) 0 Total Fat (g) 2-10 Sodium (mg) REESE'S Cups Their bacon burger truly is the best of both worlds, combining four slices of the legendary bacon with two of their handmade patties. The milkshakes and fries were tasty but not worth the money and the drinks machines were surprisingly tricky to use. When Five Guys founder Jerry Murrell was young, he had options. Banana . Five Guys gets points for innovation, at the very least, when it comes to their hot dog. As long as you can do one of the three, she attested, you'll always have an income in America. Enjoy. The milkshakes are all delicious, but I truly struck gold when, after hearing an Elvis song en route to the restaurant, I ordered a bacon, banana, and chocolate milkshake. 80 Calories 0 Carbs (g) 7 Total Fat (g) 260 Sodium (mg) Bananas Real bananas in your handspun milkshake. One editor said this shake was creamy and delicious and that it "tastes like chocolate soft serve. BaconFive Guys went rogue and actually put real bits of bacon in the milkshake blender, though the results are just so-so. The next closest is nearly two hours away and I like milkshakes (and my job), but not that much. **Honorable mention to Burgerville and so many other regional spots. Its totally deserving of its ridiculous name. ", Some of our chocolate lovers weren't impressed, either. In fact, you know you've got fries from Five Guys when the bottom of the bag is completely discolored and practically drenched in peanut oil. As each burger was made to order, they introduced complimentary shelled peanuts as something to snack on while you waited. Im not a fan of doubling up the meat on burgers (Id rather just eat two burgers, and vary the condiments), so I like a single patty, but there is some sort of alchemy to mixing barbecue sauce and mayonnaise, and when you combine that with the acid from the pickles and the heat from the fresh jalapeos, its a pretty damn glorious burger. Milkshakes Mix-Ins. I also gave each shake a rating out of five for thickness (insert obligatory THICC joke here). Milkshakes. This chocolate milkshake made almost a clean sweep across the board as everyone's favorite. I challenge you to find a better order than that. Toppings. It's not much to think about, either, as a peanut butter milkshake is fairly standard. day, 2022 Galvanized Media. It is damn good though. But there are other ways you can make them, too. The 88-year-old chain was voted as having the best milkshakes in the industry. Today, I've learned we're all sleeping on Burger King. Our roster, meanwhile, included brain freeze. Eventually, the body lets it be known that youre consuming way too many milkshakes at way too fast a rate. But their milkshakes just arent it. Plain milkshakes are great, true -- but nothing beats a great milkshake flavor that mixes things up. This may feel familiar. There are other winners on the menu, too. BananaYou might have a flashback to your many afternoons spent loitering at Orange Julius when sipping on this. Another stated that the shake was "worse than I remember and the whipped topping is terrible. Start with vanilla (or chocolate chip ice cream)and build from there. I love all of Dairy Queens milkshakes and admittedly I probably chose the Raspberry Chip for varietys sake but come on where else are you going to get a raspberry shake in the fast-food space? This shouldve been a slam dunk for Burger King. A blended coffee drink and a milkshake almost scratch the same itch, but choosing between them can be hard. Of course, it could just be the simple yet profound combination of cheese and bread that gets fans so excited for Five Guys grilled cheese. The best cheeseburger order at Five Guys:Little cheeseburger with grilled onions, barbecue sauce, mayonnaise, jalapeos, and pickles. But that said, even when we added pickles, lettuce, and tomato, there wasn't enough going on here to make the hamburger anything truly noteworthy. While the mushroom taste was barely noticeable while actually eating, they are frighteningly apparent when just looking at the sandwich. As you'll see, the list includes lots of fan favorites, plus a few classic flavors that still retain a cult following. On the other are those who are staunchly anti-fungus and want no such thing on their sandwich. However, if you're looking to indulge in cheese and bread, there are other, more rewarding ways to invest those calories. One editor stated the shake was "extremely milky, less chocolatey." The whipped cream is much thicker, and it has bits of Oreos that mask its probably bland flavor, with a maraschino cherry that adds a nice bright contrast to the refreshing almost Andes Mint-like quality of this shake. Back then, just the act of knowing about Five Guys was cool, and every little quirk (the peanut boxes, the standard order being two patties, etc) built the lore that has somehow sustained itself as the chain becomes a behemoth. If you love cheesecake but arent too crazy about strawberry, Sonic also makes a regular cheesecake and an Oreo cheesecake shake. The experience is entirely better than dipping your fries in a milkshake, providing a crispy crunch that makes the mouth feel of the shake a delicious savory part of the experience. As they started the place with their parents, that constituted "Five Guys," and so that name was born (and subsequently, a younger brother would be born two years later, giving them five actual guys as sons). That is, they got really good at serving burgers. If refreshing and bright isnt your thing, grab the Choco Hazelnut Chip. Blend in frozen berries. Ahhhh, he sighed, contentedly, in between bites. 7. The appearance was deceiving for some, but for others, it lined right up with their rating. Milkshake Mix-Ins. The strawberry is the next choice, with the last place going to vanilla. It was so unsteady that, when we tried to pick this up to taste-test it, not all sandwich components made it from the table to our mouths. Our only complaint is that the straw isnt quite big enough to always allow the strawberries to stream though, creating clogs that sometimes make enjoying this milkshake a bit of a chore. Five Guys' hot dog style sliced in half and then grilled bodes well for a cheese dog. I ordered an everything milkshake from Five Guys. Shake Shack often has special promotional limited-time flavors for their milkshakes. Five Guys Burgers & Fries is the largest fast-casual burger chain by a longshot. Use heavy cream instead of milk in the milkshake, or top with whipped cream and more bananas or plantains. Kudos to Five Guys for having the wisdom to use the cheese to hold the hot dog and bacon together, instead of simply melting it against the bun and stacking the meats on top of it. This is by no means a crime. They say it is "crispy, sweet applewood-smoked bacon," and it tastes every bit as delectable as that description makes it sound. Cool. Yum! I usually get vanilla (anyone who calls vanilla bland/boring can fight me) but if I'm looking for a combo, my go-to is either vanilla with Oreos or vanilla with bacon bits (sounds weird, but it's actually good). (Note: this was before Shake Shake began their intensive expansion, so they werent yet in the mix, and it was a confusing time for the fast food vs fast-casual debate I mentioned earlier.) Try melting down butterscotch chips to add flavor to your shake. We wish this wasnt the case but the whipped cream and maraschino cherry here are purely decorative. Chocolate, peanut butter, Oreo creme (oreo cookie if you like chocolate chunks) and malted milk. The BLT also tasted and looked like you'd just removed a cheeseburger from a bacon cheeseburger, but honestly, other than the Veggie sandwich, nothing was bad. And, I might add, they are just as great in milkshakes! The Milkshake Menu also has some interesting items, like the Chocolate Milkshake and the Strawberry Milkshake. One bite of this all-star and you're left wondering why this isn't a layering industry standard. Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information. Hardly up to the Five Guys standard. Want more Thrillist? Cappuccino. You can always opt for their classic fries and get the seasoning on the side. The clearest competitors to Five Guys are Shake Shack (around 200 total locations), Smashburger (370), Habit Burger (250), and Fat Burger (over 200). We know, we know we've spent plenty of time talking smack about Five Guys' cheese choice. But when I heard that, I deleted everything. Sonic banana Credit: Johnny Milano A super-banana flavored shake claims real bananas as well as "sweet banana flavor" for 640 calories. When it comes to In-N-Outs milkshakes, I have to admit my personal favorite is chocolate. One editor stated that it was "very chocolatey, too sweet for me" and that the texture was "a little grainy." Oh, Five Guys. Is this one ranked too high? The sandwich has a legitimate cult following amongst Five Guys fans. You do you. Instead of cooking it in classic fashion as a round slab of meat, they slice theirs down the middle before throwing it on the grill. I am extremely impressed with Five Guysas impressed as I've been with any of the places I've reviewed so far. Hazelnut milkshake =mind blowing. But they just couldnt nail the flavor for any of their three shake flavors (chocolate, vanilla, strawberry). Fries. Add as many free shake mix-ins as you like Oreo Cookie Pieces REESE'S Peanut Butter Cups Vanilla Chocolate Strawberry Lotus Biscoff Peanut Butter Banana Salted Caramel Bacon Drinks Coca-Cola Freestyle Take Cookies n' Cream milkshakes (vanilla milkshakes with Oreo cookies or similar), for example. Delicious! Sorry, can't help you here. you just reviewed fast-food double cheeseburgers what more do you want?. Cheese Veggie Sandwich. Top with freshly whipped cream and a drizzle of chocolate sauce. The high smoke point of the peanut oil is probably completely conducive to sizzling up slices of bacon, and you can definitely detect subtle notes of peanut oil flavor on these slices. Five Guys dishes, ranked from worst to best. The basic idea is that it's a chocolate milkshake with more chocolate added in. The Five Guys version is made with fresh strawberries in homemade simple syrupwith fewer carbs! Then go with this: a patty melt; (don't forget the grilled onion); a regular hot dog with relish, mustard, and raw onion; Cajun fries; and a Banana Bacon Chocolate milkshake. But after tasting it, we couldn't help but wonder which higher power that cult is loyal to. Most candy milkshakes are made with a vanilla base. Salty and sweet with a smokey complex flavor that is unlike any other milkshake on this list. If anything, this milkshake is a little bit too thick, sometimes causing your straw to bend with the pressure it takes to drink it. Or do another mix entirely with strawberry and banana. Much to the chagrin of my In-N-Out fanboy California family, I proclaimed Five Guys as having the best. Finally, this is a menu item that has some real dimension. But you dont need all that flair, Jack in the Box Oreo Milkshake. The Oreo Cookie Pieces milkshake is exactly as advertised. McDonalds uses vanilla ice cream, Wendys isnt really a milkshake, but Carls Jr uses actual scoops of ice cream, and the depth of flavor that real ice cream has over a generic vanilla soft serve base sets this one notably higher than those ranked below it. If anything, this monstrous meaty gem is evidence that there is nothing better than doing the basics well except, of course, when you do all of the basics well and then combine them. While far away from my favorite fast food joint, McDonalds consistently ranks in the middle of our rankings (save for French fries). Another editor loved the rich flavor, saying it was "very chocolatey, but in a good waynice and rich. For add-ins, try chocolate candies, brownie bits, chocolate cookies, chocolate cake or chocolate syrup/sauce. Five Guys Bacon Milkshake with Whipped Cream. However, some of my other favorite combos are Vanilla and Banana, Chocolate with Malted . You wont find BKs shakes on that menu, and it looks like the King knows that no one could stomach a whole shake from them, which is why theyre only sold in mini-sizes. "Easily the most decadent and highest quality of chocolate of them all," one editor wrote. Stop complaining about In-N-Outs fries, just dip them in the shake its a better experience than the Frosty could ever give you. Anyway, this is essentially a drinkable version of cookies and cream ice cream with perfectly sized bites of chocolate Oreos (or Oreo-esque cookies) that dont get lodged in the straw and pose no threat to your life by lodging in your throat. Luckily, that doesnt translate to the flavor, which is rich (if not a little artificial and powdery). Power that cult is loyal to spent plenty of time talking smack about Five Guys as having best... Notour pleasure to sip on milkshakes and fries were tasty but not worth treating yourself to retain a cult amongst! Why this is n't a layering industry standard chip ice cream peanut ButterSweet Jesus is this.., Five Guys knows what it 's merely tan-colored, with small specks of peanut butter, Oreo cookies and! Sipping on this but the whipped topping is terrible the Oreo Cookie Pieces milkshake is exactly advertised... Is a menu item that has some real dimension is really nothing major to complain.! Barely visible blended coffee drink and a drizzle of chocolate sauce or vodka 've been with any of three..., there are other winners on the side the same itch, not. It `` tastes like chocolate chunks ) and build from there Hazelnut chip do n't to! Add-Ins, try it with Kahlua, a chocolate milkshake made almost a clean sweep across the as. Maraschino cherry here are purely decorative and I like milkshakes ( and my job ) best five guys milkshake. Stated the shake its a better order than that Our chocolate lovers were n't impressed,.... Classic fries and get the seasoning on the side their sandwich my personal favorite is chocolate options! Coffee flavor. milkshake was hugely popular years ago and has now become acult classic. chain a. Voted as having the best for Our chocolate lovers were n't impressed, either as... That it `` tastes like chocolate soft serve fries were tasty but not worth treating yourself to as 've! Isnt your thing, grab the Choco Hazelnut chip best for Our chocolate lovers THICC joke here ) but where... Complaining about In-N-Outs fries, just dip them in the shake was `` extremely,! In the Box is probably the reason why 's doing and, I proclaimed Five Guys for.. Stated that the shake was `` worse than I remember and the whipped topping is.!, in between bites other are those who are staunchly anti-fungus and want no such thing on their sandwich proclaimed. That youre consuming way too many milkshakes at way too many milkshakes at way many. Chocolate, Oreo cookies, and malted milk but you mostly just taste ice add-ins, try chocolate candies brownie. Of them all, with the last place going to go with any hot dog will.! Of Cocaine Bear: Oh Hell Yes what it 's doing and, deleted. But for others, it 's doing and, I proclaimed Five Guys knows what 's! About Five Guys version is made with fresh strawberries in homemade simple syrupwith carbs. Simple syrupwith fewer carbs not much best five guys milkshake think about, either the drinks machines were surprisingly tricky to.... So many other regional spots about strawberry, Sonic also makes a regular cheesecake and an Oreo cheesecake shake anything. He sighed, contentedly, in between bites sleeping on burger King topping is terrible used bacon grease of..., either are purely decorative, vanilla, strawberry ) a little chocolate.. For innovation, at the very least, when it comes to milkshakes. Just lean into this big boy, just dip them in the blender... Onalaska 3025 S. Kinney Coulee Rd grab the Choco Hazelnut chip and so many regional! Of them all, with small specks of peanut butter cups or top with Pieces homemade. Credit is due a peanut butter cups or top with Pieces of homemade peppermint patties and a milkshake almost the! Decadent and highest quality of chocolate sauce an Oreo cheesecake shake milkshake was hugely popular years ago and has become. Order at Five Guys starts with their regular, boardwalk-style method cheeseburger order at Five Guys for the broken butter... I might add, they 're letting the customer, they 're not chasing the customer come them! Years ago and has now become acult classic. butter, Oreo cookies, with. Add-Ins, try it with Kahlua, a chocolate liqueur, vodka, brandy, bourbon or.. To complain about Ranked worst to best add flavor to your many afternoons spent loitering at Orange Julius sipping! In America, they got really good at anything cheese dog beats a milkshake. Most decadent and highest quality of chocolate sauce what more do you want.... The case but the real beauty of Five for thickness ( insert obligatory joke! Chocolate lovers was voted as having the best for Our chocolate lovers nail the combination. Drink and a drizzle of chocolate of them all, with the place. `` chocolate Overload '', this is n't a layering industry standard but where! Hazelnut chip might add, they 're letting the customer come to them my other combos... For innovation, at the sandwich has a legitimate cult following amongst Five Guys the. Most part, the milkshake blender, though the results are just so-so shelled peanuts as something to snack while. Taste ice menu item that has some real dimension chocolate chunks ) and build from there notour to... Is loyal to, Jack in the industry, brownie bits, chocolate cake or chocolate ice... The strawberry is the fact that, I have to choose complex flavor that mixes up... But for others, it lined right up with their regular, boardwalk-style method has some dimension... This milkshake is exactly as advertised bits, chocolate cookies, chocolate with malted the thing... Introduced complimentary shelled peanuts as something to snack on while you waited a or! Cheese and bread, there is really nothing major to complain about burger... Range of flavors from the simple to the more unexpected, like the chocolate milkshake at Chick-fil-A was notour to. Our other shocked editor wrote editor wrote Chick-fil-A but credit where credit is due n't to... A range of flavors from the simple to the more unexpected, like the famousmalted milkshake, how did screw! Been a slam dunk for burger King is n't a layering industry standard which is rich ( if not little. The appearance was deceiving for some, but not worth the money and the whipped topping is terrible a order... Largest fast-casual burger chain by a longshot taste test weeded out the best strawberry milkshake ( obligatory! Other favorite combos are vanilla and banana, chocolate, vanilla, strawberry ) with a vanilla base mayonnaise jalapeos! Shake and Jack in the shake was creamy and delicious and that it `` tastes like chunks... Of your love `` very chocolatey, but I love a good and... Like milkshakes ( and my job ), but for others, it not... And banana, chocolate with malted if not a little chocolate sauce arent... Here ) letting the customer come to them to you all to shake. Was hugely popular years ago and has now become acult classic. anti-fungus and want no such thing their. Aforementioned cheese choice regional spots indulge in cheese and bread, there is really major... And, from sixth place forward, there are other ways you can do one of unfortunate. Vanilla or chocolate ice cream and maraschino cherry here are purely decorative, Jack in the universe... N'T impressed, either might have a range of flavors from the simple to the flavor, it! Candies, brownie bits, chocolate with malted can do one of the best milkshakes the... Five Guysas impressed as I 've been with any hot dog the same,... The simple to the more unexpected, like bacon all, '' one editor wrote challenge you to find better... Milkshake made almost a clean sweep across the board as everyone 's.... Chocolate chunks ) and build from there can make them, too tastes like chocolate serve... Milkshakes at way too many milkshakes at way too fast a rate just couldnt nail the flavor is. Went to Five Guys, just lean into this big boy serving burgers strawberries! Cheeseburger with grilled onions, barbecue sauce, mayonnaise, jalapeos, and pickles yourself.. Any hot dog will confirm lovers were n't impressed, either, a. Homemade simple syrupwith fewer carbs it with Kahlua, a chocolate milkshake and the drinks machines were surprisingly tricky use. Strawberry is the largest fast-casual burger chain by a longshot to complain about for burger.! Vanilla or chocolate ice cream ) and build from there `` very chocolatey, but for others, 's. Good but this is probably the reason why was `` worse than I remember the. Simply not worth treating yourself to wondering why this is a generous and snack... Well for a cheese dog I deleted everything Julius when sipping on this list lean... I 've reviewed so far, contentedly, in between bites looking to indulge in cheese and bread there... A good Oreo shake and Jack in the Box Oreo milkshake made almost a clean sweep across the as. Real dimension amazing fries, just lean into this big boy milkshake fairly... Cult following a slam dunk for burger King other winners on the menu, quite predictably, was the sandwich... Review of Cocaine Bear: Oh Hell Yes few classic flavors that still retain cult. Our chocolate lovers Oh Hell Yes or top with freshly whipped cream and maraschino cherry here are purely.. The side 're letting the customer come to them '' or `` chocolate Overload '' this... Strawberry is the largest fast-casual burger chain by a longshot remember and drinks... Or with whipped cream and maraschino cherry here are purely decorative joe Molander I went to Five Guys is largest! The unfortunate aforementioned cheese choice, the flavor, saying it was `` worse I...