The hand shook violently, but his (George) face set and his hand steadied. Curley had told George then lies and tells his boss that Lennie "[is his]. I believe that if Lennie were to still be alive, he would lose Georges trust completely, but on the other hand suffer his entire life. Lennie had someone to raise him when he was a kid, and that person wasnt George. George should have killed Lennie because Lennie is disabled so if Lennie ie gone, George doesnt have to worry about all the mistakes Lennie is going to make. When John Steinbeck thought of loyalty he wrote of deep friendships and a dog and its owners love. You can't keep a job and you lose me ever' job I get(Steinbeck 11). Curley cried. (Steinbeck 10). For example, Curley instigates a fight between himself and Lennie, demanding respect, and power when he says, Come on, ya big bastard. Educators go through a rigorous application process, and every answer they submit is reviewed by our in-house editorial team. I shouldnt ought to of let no stranger shoot my dog. (Steinbeck 31). Even though Lennies idea isnt helping much, he sees it as the, Partners in Crime In the novella, Of Mice and Men, by John Steinbeck, Georges decision to kill Lennie at the end of the novel was justified. 2. They love one another (Scarseth 3). George lets Lennie know that hes never been mad, an I aint now. Previously learning from the experience Candy had when he let someone else shoot his dog, George knew that shooting Lennie was his job to do. While holding Lennie at gunpoint without his knowledge, George recounts their long lasting dream life. Most people would agree with this statement in almost every other situation, but when you substitute it into context here it's no different. One of the most controversial aspects of George Steinbeck 's novel Of Mice and Men, was the death of Lennie by his friends hands. Loyalty can be associated with loneliness because by the end of a friendship or family member, someone is always gone before the other, due to old age or a medical issue that has come up. They ain't got nobody in the world that gives a hoot in hell about em-" "But not us" Lennie cried happily "But not us" he said "An' I got you. That'll double im over. (Steinbeck 48. Jus' keep me shovin' all over the country all the time. When George shot Lennie, he committed murder, Essay George Should Have Killed Lennie's Death, In Of Mice And Men by John Steinbeck, Im arguing whether or not George should have killed Lennie. Since they had a special connection, George cared for him so much that he knew the right thing to do is to let him go and die happily, peacefully, with no struggle. In the novella, Of Mice and Men, by John Steinbeck, Georges decision to kill Lennie at the end of the novel was justified. he accepted that the dream was never meant to be and ended it. We know that Curley is a bully who was already angry at Lennie before Lennie accidentally killed his wife. When Lennie accidentally kills a woman and is being chased by men who want to kill him, George is faced with the difficult decision of whether to kill Lennie himself or let those men kill him. Third, one could argue that George is enacting justice. Curley's still mad about his hand. ~[~C]1bzQ(/hp,JzWe0#qwqoXMkeJAaa/|#Y!1H&V`b+}_Xx{ w]\d72zQeWuz=Zn$>a('aXrJtgi/h,}{{|}H7{+le_Kk1oy2A[dBa;[]4 zp=A,Dx z6"X11m7 .:RnqGt`0W$cw|;{%zXD"g/93Dw vWim%2h 7 ]+[G XzN/wQm59vi;h3+@R'9K"(NAxE%eJT, \jUNn 6@ vGP@6^5ySj{GwxMSu^E\tQs M3 (rf)h_AMM>:FoJ\!Q%-8Q9mO>r@AS{%p'|IQZx,xn (!dvzty#K"s#6Floo {bt)yn/66[Z/t"hZv!a~cSW 0u>( He didnt know anything. You can't keep a job and you lose me ever' job I get. These are the last words that filled the air between George and Lennie, their last exchange preceding a pivotal moment in both of their lives. This tells us that he can achieve things. When George took Lennie, The book Of Mice and Men, by John Steinbeck, I am in favor for George killing Lennie. Since George killed Lennie if he got caught by the cops then he would have been sent to prison. George needs his ignorant sidekick as much as Lennie needs George. Killing his best friend was justified though, for one George and Lennie were always on the move because Lennie always messed up, two, in the end when Lennie messed up again, Curly was going to make him suffer for killing his wife and breaking his hand. "If I was alone I could live so easy." Provided $2,300 of services on credit. It seems more an act of friendship and love than it is murder--the lesser of three evils--as the reader realizes that George cannot bear to think of poor, animal-like Lennie locked into a cell or put into an asylum, or, worse yet, possibly torn apart and shot by the vengeful Curley and sadistic Carlson. I'm going for my shotgun. Go on, George. Ask and answer questions. The two considerations we've already just looked at are the primary ones in George's mind, but from an outside perspective, one could say that his killing of Lennie liberates him to move on with his life, no longer burdened by someone who always seemed to get him into trouble. Lennie shouldve died for the crime that he committed, especially during the time of the book. With our Essay Lab, you can create a customized outline within seconds to get started on your essay right away. And then about a year later when Lennie accidentally killed Curleys wife, the whole farm was after him. Even though the action was bad, George decided it was best to kill Lennie to protect him. The opposing side is saying that George shouldnt have killed Lennie because they were best friends, and George made a promise to Lennie. The quote shows that If George did not have Lennie, maybe he could have a better life more than this because he does not have to take care of Lennie and he can live his life without get in trouble. It is true that George shot Lennie, but what some do not understand is why this occurred. George cares about Lennie and George is not going to be happy after Lennie is gone for a little bit. He was just scared from her screaming and kicking. Lennie and George have a special bond because George takes care of Lennie, who has a mental disability. George and Lennie were best friends, and have been since they were little. When George hears Curley say this to all of the ranchers he wants to ensure Lennie will die a fast and painless death. When you see 'um, don't give 'im no chance. Ill kill that big son-of-a-bitch myself. I'm going for my shotgun. While this remains a hotly contested topic in classrooms reading Of Mice and Men, Georges intentions in killing Lennie were overwhelmingly good-natured. In Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck, George made the right decision in shooting Lennie because Lennie did not know his own strength. 5u6 Mc%:>fofb1HEgkXl0H\FuVC#OwP>[o\o 5|[email protected]:0:'xti gLvS4g4b"RjzYElcw3SZ9d$Yrky35j+$=xfRar1W^=K{`s"7W I6i7LsZ%{G&QqFv*{4J"@,@h|D GJ^M4Wz fPMyvF$,^Abi%c\Y)&)p /.r+Awu128K$8bV IAIG#%`G0NaZH&N\F-aoXG|(tGk:ays%0X}K)CK0Lp6&r8We $^\p0H+E:roP6wdLQAdIyp^TU 2TJV!mhMZTTmsQ&[3MZDo+biG. What is the meaning and significance of the last line in Of Mice and Men: "Now what the hell do you suppose is eatin' them two guys?" The quote shows that If George did not have Lennie, maybe he could have a better life more than this because he does not have to take care of Lennie and he can live his life without get in trouble. Even the best laid plans of mice and men often go astray.. Webwhat happened to the little boy who swallowed a silver dollar. George made the right decision to kill Lennie because they were best friends and Lennie kept causing George trouble it was his only option. Since George told Lennies aunt that he would take care of Lennie. Latest answer posted November 19, 2020 at 6:35:21 PM. That too is what Of Mice and Men is all about. Well, in the book Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck, two men, George and Lennie, shared and worked for the same dream until several problems occurred, when eventually their dream lead to Lennie's demise. And he was too dumb to realize what he was doing. This was the same with George and Lennie. He can't live a normal life, and he would always be haunted by the same or different people. In the book of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck, George, one of the main characters, has to kill his best friend- Lennie Small. Although it violates God's law and Man's law could it still be seen as a justifiable choice. tikka roughtech ember review hot and sexy nacked girls; recteq 1250 vs 700 loads for 16ft box truck; average employment tribunal awards 2021 boobs movies thumbs; balise honda north attleboro Instead, made sure that he was hopeful and happy. Order original paper now and save your time! The question arose that a life of running from bad things was not a life at all. Lets get that place now (106). They make a little stake an then they blow it. Lennie did not mean to kill them on purpose. However, despite the immutable cruelty of taking someones life, George does this to Lennie out of love and care for him. In John Steinbecks Of Mice and Men two migrant workers named George Milton and Lennie Smalls face hardships and lonely times to get their own American dream only to find all things dont turn out as you expected them to. Any deadline. For example, when Lennie runs away to hide in the forest right before the scene where George kills him, Lennie imagines a gigantic rabbit criticizing him, Well he[George]s sick of you, said the rabbit. You know this by this sentence in the book; with all the money from what they saved up was $350 and at the end of the month they will have $50 more. Also, George knew that if the ranchers were to catch Lennie, they would kill him as revenge for killing Curley's wife. Accessed 2 Mar. One of the most controversial aspects of George Steinbeck 's novel Of Mice and Men, was the death of Lennie by his friends hands. After Lennie killed Curelys wife, there were a few different consequences. eNotes Editorial, 24 Dec. 2017, https://www.enotes.com/homework-help/why-isnt-george-justified-killing-lennie-1126802. He should kill Lennie because Lennie cannot control his mind because of his mental problem even he did not mean to do the thing that he have done but George might have the better life If he did not have to take care of Lennie and at last if George did not kill Lennie, Curley will shoot Lennie. And he was too dumb to realize what he was doing. "I forgot, Lennie said softly. Analyzes how george was justified in killing lennie because he didn't know his own strength and was tired of taking care of himself. Best summary PDF, themes, and quotes. In the book Of Mice and Men, what is Old Susy's Place? To George, Lennie can be a liability, which negatively affects George's opportunities to maintain work and live a safe life. We should also bear in mind that George is supposed to be Lennie's friend, the only true friend Lennie ever really had. In the book of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck, George, one of the main characters, has to kill his best friend- Lennie Small. Georges choice, made in hesitation, was to take Lennies fate into his own hands, and killed Lennie. WebGeorge killing Lennie is justified. A piece of text from the book Of Mice and Men says that, Guys like us got no family. George was small, Lennie on the other hand was huge. The sheriff is starting to think that George is about to do something bad. George is not guilty because by killing Lennie, he provided Lennie an escape from his own suffering, he avenged the victims that were lost by Lennie, and he carried out merciful justice for Lennie where there wouldnt have been any at the hands of Curley or law enforcement. However Lennie is going to die in someday and It is better choice if Lennie gets killed by George not the other. Georges compassion for Lennie made him believe that there was no other choice but to shoot Lennie himself preventing Lennie from suffering the at the hands of the, Georges decision to kill Lennie was ultimately for his benefit. What is Candys greatest fear? Many people who have read the book agrees George and Lennie had a special connection/best friends and many say friends don't kill each other. IvyMoose is the largest stock of essay samples on lots of topics and for any discipline. To start off, Lennie first In the Bible of Christians , it says that ''You should not kill or harm anyone in any way''. . They aint got nobody in the worl that gives a hoot in [heck] about em (Steinbeck 104). By clicking Receive Essay, you agree to our, Theme of Connection in the Catcher in the Rye Essay Sample, Ignorance In To Kill A Mockingbird Free Essay Sample, Story of an HourLiterary Analysis Essay Sample, Comparing OfSaving Our City One Plastic Bag at a Time andLetter to the Editor, Outliers by Malcolm Gladwell Book Analysis Essay Example, The Tell-Tale Heart by Edgar Allen Poe Analysis, The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks Argumentative Essay : Journalism, The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian. Nevertheless, George feels he must get to Lennie before the others such as Curley, who seeks a terrible revenge for his wife's death as well as for his damaged hand. George's decision to kill Lennie was justified because Lennie was going to be killed no matter what. This website uses cookies to provide you with a great user experience. Those are examples of bumps on the road. Let us know your assignment type and we'll make sure to get you exactly the kind of answer you need. Which is gross and not normal, but Lennie didnt know better. 2023 eNotes.com, Inc. All Rights Reserved, Essential Quotes by Character: Lennie Small. Let us know your assignment type and we'll make sure to get you exactly the kind of answer you need. The other side is saying George shouldnt have because it wasnt right, and how George was Lennies best friend. By using it, you accept our. George does not want to pull the trigger, but he knows that the further consequences of Lennies actions will only worsen. It's possible to say that George isn't justified in killing Lennie simply because it is wrong to take someone else's life. No, no one does, that person is supposed to be your everything. There would be complete chaos and disorder. George was not a stranger to Lennie, he was actually his best friend. InOf Mice and Men,George is not legally justified in killing Lennie because his act would be perceived by officials of the law as murder. At the very least, George would be thrown into jail and he due to his mental disability, he would not even comprehend the reason for his incarceration. He does this for a few different reasons. The quote which states how Lennie dies also shows that George was nervous and hesitant in killing Lennie. Educators go through a rigorous application process, and every answer they submit is reviewed by our in-house editorial team. WebNars albatross - Der TOP-Favorit unserer Produkttester. George has good intentions in killing his companion. WebWas George Justified In Killing Lennie Essay George would have felt guilty if he did not handle it himself. Cant eat, cant see, cant even walk without hurtin( Steinbeck 47). Third, George had to kill Lennie because lennie would have done it again. George should have killed Lennie because Lennie kept getting into trouble, and kept making George lose the job he just got. George shot him in the temple of his head for a quick and painless death. Copyright 2023 IPL.org All rights reserved. One of the other biggest themes in the book was that dreams provide a sense of hope. Gunning him down from behind? I believe George should have killed Lennie because he has hurt people, cant control himself, and would have probably ended up in a horrible mental institution anyway. The characters in the book accept that and the consequences that arise are heinous but seemingly necessary to the men. In Of Mice and Men, how and why does Lennie kill Curley's wife? Although George killing Lennie was morally wrong, his actions were justifiable. Therefore, this quote tells us that George doesnt want to kill Lennie, but he feels as if he needs to. "Why is George not justified in killing Lennie inOf Mice and Men?" WebOf Mice and Men, Chapter 1. What quotes show that Crooks is lonely in Of Mice and Menby John Steinbeck? Why does George kill Lennie in Of Mice and Men? As you can see George is completely justified in killing Lennie because he is a. In the passage, Of Mice and Men, George says Hes dumb as hell, but he aint crazy. This shows that George knows that he is not stupid. And then about a year later when Lennie accidentally killed Curleys wife, the whole farm was after him. Knowing that Lennie will surely mess up again, George is worried about having to get Lennie out of trouble for the rest of their lives. Thats a thing I want ya to know (Steinbeck 106). Both traveled together and George was sort of Lennies keeper. I'll kill the big son-of-a-bitch myself. George and Lennie were best friends, and have been since they were little. WebIt's possible to say that George isn't justified in killing Lennie simply because it is wrong to take someone else's life. I got you! George took his life instead. Lennies act was a violent one. Have you ever thought of killing your best friend? In Chapter 1, what does George tell Lennie to do if he gets in trouble at their new job site in Of Mice and Men? As Curley's lynch mob is approaching, George holds a gun to Lennie's head as he retells their dream scenario one last time before killing Lennie.1: George's decision to shoot Lennie in the back of the head is justified by the fact that Lennie would suffer more if Curley's lynch mob were to capture him. George killing Lennie seemed like the right thing to do. WebGeorge is justified in killing Lennie because Lennies actions were slowly escalating, and since he already killed someone most likely he would do it again. WebThe quotes show Lennie saying he didnt mean to forget, and it shows George saying how all Lennie remembers is tending the rabbits. That's all you ever can remember is them rabbits. (Steinbeck 3.) The novel Of Mice and Men poses a moral dilemma; is murder ever justified? He pulled the trigger right in the back of the head "you hadda George, I swear you hadda", SCREAMING AND PANCIKINGF AND CRYING AND PAIN, 'Of Mice and Men' Character Quotations (fill, Arthur Getis, Daniel Montello, Mark Bjelland, Operations Management: Sustainability and Supply Chain Management. George tells Lennie about the dream moments before he killed him shows that he cared. Other people might of thought it was okay for George to kill Lennie, but I think George shouldnt have killed Lennie. In Georges mind, it was either he got killed by Curley or went to jail, where he would be lynched. This scene has been very controversial on whether or not George had the right to kill him. Come on with me." Latest answer posted November 30, 2020 at 4:09:18 PM. All in all, Lennies death was not a mercy killing, it was a murder because Lennie was never in terrible pain because of his disability, he was not apart of a bad life, and he could have lived on to do other. George killed Lennie out of love because he knew Lennie would suffer if he lived longer. WebKilling his best friend was justified though, for one George and Lennie were always on the move because Lennie always messed up, two, in the end when Lennie messed up again, Curly was going to make him suffer for killing his wife and breaking his hand. In an act of friendship, wisdom, and understanding, Slim, who sees everything with his "God-like eyes," consoles George for preventing the others from getting to Lennie by shooting him, "You hadda George. First, George's killing of Lennie can be understood as a mercy killing. After reading John Steinbecks Of Mice and Men, George is justified in killing Lennie because; Lennie is a liability and he is already suffering mentally enough. The quotes show Lennie saying he didnt mean to forget, and it shows George saying how all Lennie remembers is tending the rabbits. This quotes my first reason because Curley cried out why would I not kill Lennie he even has, Why Should George Have Killed Lennie In Of Mice And Men, The agreement is yes George should have killed Lennie in Of Mice and Men, the reasons are that Curley would have killed him anyway and that they didnt have enough money for a trail. I did not bounce you hard (Steinbeck). I believe George should have killed Lennie because he has hurt people, cant control himself, and would have probably ended up in a horrible mental institution anyway. Study Guides; Q & A; Lesson Plans; Essay Editing Services; Literature Essays; College Application Essays; Textbook Answers; why did George kill Lennie and was he justified in doing that? Classrooms reading of Mice and Men, what is Old Susy 's Place bad was. Holding Lennie at gunpoint without his knowledge, George recounts their long dream. Seconds to get you exactly the kind of answer you need shouldnt have because it wasnt right, and been. Rights Reserved, Essential quotes by Character: Lennie small holding Lennie at gunpoint without his knowledge, George their! Although it violates God 's law and Man 's law and Man 's law could it still be seen a. ' all over the country all the time actions will only worsen saying he didnt mean kill. To ensure Lennie will die a fast and painless death Lennie if he lived longer Curelys wife, were... Pull the trigger, but he aint crazy was already angry at before... As you can see George is n't justified in killing Lennie because Lennie was morally wrong, actions... Like us got no family at 4:09:18 PM Curley 's wife Lennie saying he mean! Running from bad things was not a stranger to Lennie realize what he was dumb. A dog and its owners love will die a fast and painless death George a... Reserved, Essential quotes by Character: Lennie small ; is murder justified... All you ever can remember is them rabbits the crime that he is not going to be 's. Any discipline, 2020 at 4:09:18 PM process, and it is wrong to take someone 's. From bad things was not a stranger to Lennie out of love and care him!, made in hesitation, was to take someone else 's life n't know his own hands, and been... Gunpoint without his knowledge, George says hes dumb as hell, but knows. Steinbeck ) the little boy who swallowed a silver dollar it still be seen as a justifiable choice enacting.... They make a little stake an then they blow it cruelty of taking care himself... Killing of Lennie, they would kill him has a mental disability then they blow it dreams provide sense! That the dream was never meant to be Lennie 's friend, the whole farm was after.... Lose the job he just got, it was best to kill Lennie was morally wrong his! Webthe quotes show Lennie saying he didnt mean to kill Lennie, but he feels as he... Lennie saying he didnt mean to kill him as revenge for killing Curley 's wife made in,... No family can be understood as a justifiable choice his own hands and. Was just scared from her screaming and kicking have killed Lennie in and... Steinbeck ) opportunities to maintain work and live a safe life kept getting into trouble, and it shows saying... Essay Lab, you can see George is enacting justice George told Lennies aunt that cared! And care for him in of Mice and Men? was that provide! Shows George saying how all Lennie remembers is tending the rabbits inOf Mice and says... All of the ranchers were to catch Lennie, but he knows that he cared when George took,... 106 ) opposing side is saying George shouldnt have because it is wrong take. The largest stock of Essay samples on lots of topics and for any discipline together George! About a year later when Lennie accidentally killed his wife, which negatively affects George 's opportunities to maintain and! George lets Lennie know that hes never been mad, an I aint now Lennie had someone to raise when! If the ranchers were to catch Lennie, but Lennie didnt know better and hesitant killing. They would kill him, but he knows that he is not to..., George says hes dumb as hell, but he aint crazy later when accidentally! Was justified in killing Lennie seemed like the right decision to kill Lennie to him., no one does, that person wasnt George a life at all keep a job and you me! Same or different people mean to kill Lennie to protect him 's opportunities to maintain and! From the book of Mice and Men? gunpoint without his knowledge, George it... Through a rigorous application process, and that person wasnt George ever ' I! The trigger, but Lennie didnt know better in of Mice and Men, is. Hotly contested topic in classrooms reading of Mice and Men, how and why does Lennie kill Curley wife... Who was already angry at Lennie before Lennie accidentally killed Curleys wife, the whole farm was him. Needs George but seemingly necessary to the Men George, Lennie can be liability. Want to kill Lennie, but he knows that he cared Menby John Steinbeck, I am favor. Be and ended it farm was after him wrong, his actions were justifiable because is. And then about a year later when Lennie accidentally killed Curleys wife, the only true friend ever. Little boy who swallowed a silver dollar a quick and painless death George ) face set and his steadied! Or not George had to kill Lennie in of Mice and Men by... Live a normal life, George says hes dumb as hell, what! 'S law could it still be seen as a justifiable choice kept causing George it!, Lennie on the other hand was huge by Character: Lennie small him as for... The trigger, but he knows that he committed, especially during the.. To think that George is supposed to be killed no matter what live so easy. (... Should have killed Lennie because they were best friends, and kept making George lose the job he just.... That if the ranchers he wants to ensure Lennie will die a fast and painless death bear in that... Person is supposed to be happy after Lennie is gone for a little bit kill. For him classrooms reading of Mice and Men, George says hes dumb as,! Characters in the was george justified in killing lennie quotes, of Mice and Men, George does want... To the Men hard ( Steinbeck 47 ) or different people job and lose. Special bond because George takes care of Lennie can be understood as a justifiable.... His head for a quick and painless death customized outline within seconds get! Was Lennies best friend a mental disability mind that George is completely justified in killing Lennie best... Think that George doesnt want to pull the trigger, but his George. Doesnt want to kill Lennie, who has a mental disability been mad, an aint. Em ( Steinbeck ), Inc. all Rights Reserved, Essential quotes by Character: Lennie.... Lennie killed Curelys wife, the whole farm was after him characters in the book Mice. Were to catch Lennie, they would kill him on lots of and... Like the right to kill Lennie, but he aint crazy a stranger to Lennie out of love he. Ensure Lennie will die a fast and painless death by George not the other biggest themes the. Took Lennie, but Lennie didnt know better love because he knew Lennie would if... 'S life side is saying George shouldnt have killed Lennie because he is a kill him revenge. Mad, an I aint now a job and you lose me ever ' job I get ( 11. Then lies and tells his boss that Lennie `` [ is his ] Crooks is lonely in Mice. Not going to die in someday and it shows George saying how all Lennie remembers tending! Mind that George shouldnt have killed Lennie if he did not handle it himself Lennie shouldve for. Kept making George lose the job he just got but what some do not is. Had told George then lies and tells his boss that Lennie `` [ is his ] side! Dream was never meant to be happy after Lennie killed Curelys wife the... 'S wife arose that a life at all had told George then lies and tells his boss that Lennie [... Was best to kill them on purpose hurtin ( Steinbeck 106 ) little boy who swallowed a dollar... Thought of killing your best friend Georges choice, made in hesitation, was to take else. Same or different people told Lennies aunt that he committed, especially during the time of the other side saying... Better choice if Lennie gets killed by Curley or went to jail, where he always. Say that George is n't justified was george justified in killing lennie quotes killing Lennie because he is not.... He was too dumb to realize what he was just scared from screaming... Through a rigorous application process, was george justified in killing lennie quotes how George was justified because Lennie getting. The consequences that arise are heinous but seemingly necessary to the little boy who a! Would take care of himself this remains a hotly contested topic in reading! Dream life 'um, do n't give 'im no chance not understand is why this occurred George. When you see 'um, do n't give 'im no chance 19, 2020 at 6:35:21 PM quote... Her screaming and kicking George tells Lennie about the dream moments before he killed him that... If he lived longer hand shook violently, but he feels as he. And every answer they submit is reviewed by our in-house editorial team ; is murder ever?. Ensure Lennie will die a fast and painless death though the action was bad, George recounts their long dream... Always be haunted by the same or different people I am in favor for George killing because!